Manchester United plans a 10-man shortlist to strengthen their defense, led by a free transfer defender! Everton’s prodigy returns to the scouting list.

In the first 16 matches of this Premier League season, Manchester United let in 26 goals, the most among the top 13 clubs. The clean sheet against Newcastle on Boxing Day was largely thanks to Newcastle’s weak finishing. Insiders say United is looking to bolster their defense, with around 10 players identified by the recruitment team to make Ruben Amorim’s 3-4-3 formation less fragile at the back.

Although recent transfer rumors around Manchester United mainly focus on signing midfielders for 2026, the defense also needs reinforcement. It’s not just the wing-back positions, which are crucial for Amorim’s 3-4-3 setup, but also the central defenders have repeatedly faced issues this season. Especially Lenni Jääskeläinen, the highest-priced defender, who has made multiple mistakes in recent games.

Dean Jones, a transfer expert from the English media outlet TEAMtalk, revealed that Manchester United is searching for a well-qualified center-back to ensure the three-defender system can continue developing. This need becomes even more urgent if the club is to compete in European competitions next season.

Jones stated: "I've heard Manchester United is compiling a transfer list targeting defensive reinforcements for 2026. The list reportedly includes about 10 names, some from the Premier League but mostly from other parts of Europe. The defense, which has been stable for two years, has recently become worrying because suddenly Mazraoui, De Ligt, and Maguire are all unavailable, raising doubts about how the three-back system can be sustained."

Manchester United also has concerns about the injury status of Argentine international Lisandro Martínez. "Lima has returned to the pitch, but obviously, you have to be cautious about his performance after returning. From what I understand, United is eager to bring in another capable player to ensure continued progress. Their attempt to sign Semenyo shows the club is not just focused on the present. It’s about ensuring better performance next season, whether within Amorim’s system or otherwise, and not only adapting to the Premier League but also potential European competition."

Jones summarized: "Manchester United’s plan definitely includes some defensive signings in the summer. Considering they are only three points off the top four, I wouldn’t be surprised if the club accelerates its recruitment. The Premier League race this season is very open. Although United’s performances have not been entirely convincing, they still have a chance to qualify for the Champions League, which was the goal set at the start of the season. The midfield remains a major issue, and they are working on solutions, but United hopes to improve in as many areas as possible."

Among the rumored 10-man shortlist is definitely England international Marc Guéhi, who has confirmed he will not renew his contract with Crystal Palace. Up to 13 clubs have negotiated with the 25-year-old defender’s agent. Currently, Guéhi has not agreed on any future transfer with any club. As a top free agent, Manchester United’s pursuit of Guéhi will certainly be challenging and will require securing a Champions League spot to be eligible to compete for him.

According to “Insight Offside,” Everton’s Jarrod Branswell has once again become a target for the Red Devils. This left-footed center-back’s qualities, such as calm ball control and physical attributes, might fit very well with Amorim’s tactical system. His Premier League experience also meets Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s recruitment standards.

The 23-year-old Branswell has long been linked with Manchester United, but Everton’s £70 million valuation has prevented a deal. Branswell was heavily mocked after gifting Manchester United a chance at Old Trafford. However, since Moyes’ return, Everton’s performance has stabilized, and Branswell has played well. Of course, his price remains the biggest obstacle for a transfer, with injuries being another concern.

Amorim’s Manchester United has made significant progress offensively this season, but this has come partly at the expense of defense. His team either attacks aggressively without regard for defense, trying to outscore opponents by one goal, or, like in the second half against Newcastle, abandons attack to defend fully. They are still far from achieving a balanced approach between offense and defense.