Is Tomoyuki Sugano's one-year stint in the U.S. over? Sharp critique from American media suggests he may only secure a minor league contract.

Will former Tokyo Yomiuri Giants ace Tomoyuki Sugano’s dream of playing in the U.S. end after just one year? With the season concluded, Sugano has officially become a free agent. Despite reaching double-digit wins in his first MLB season, his elevated ERA and tendency to give up home runs have polarized opinions among U.S. media. Some local outlets bluntly state that the Baltimore Orioles have no reason to prioritize re-signing him, and if Sugano wants to stay in the U.S., he might only land a minor league deal.

Now 36 years old, Sugano signed a one-year, $13 million contract with the Orioles during last offseason. This season, he started 30 games, finishing with a 10-10 record and a 4.64 ERA. Over 157 innings pitched, he allowed 33 home runs—the highest in the American League—and opponents batted an impressive .276 against him.

The American outlet Birds Watcher noted in its report: “Although Sugano has expressed a desire to remain in Baltimore, the team has no compelling reason to prioritize him as a key reinforcement.” The report highlights his age and declining effectiveness as real concerns. However, it also mentions a possible route: if Sugano does not plan to return to Japan, the Orioles or other MLB teams might be willing to offer him a minor league contract with a spring training invitation to deepen their pitching staff.

While Shohei Ohtani and Yoshinobu Yamamoto have shined brilliantly in the U.S., Sugano’s first year abroad, despite reaching the 10-win mark, failed to demonstrate dominant performance. Currently, his former NPB team, the Yomiuri Giants, remain open to welcoming the veteran back. This winter’s decision—whether to stay in the highly competitive MLB system or make a triumphant return to NPB—will be crucial.